TaintedLogic's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Windy]

I like the concept a lot. It's pensive and inward-looking, and the somewhat simplistic design calls attention to the abstract thinking behind it. The animation quality is not superb, but for what it is I like it. :)

sleepFacingWest responds:

thanks! I'd really like to get better at animation, but I have NO idea what I'm doing. It's a hobby I'd like to pursue under the occasional guidance of those who know more than me.

[An odd dish]

Great work! I like the drama, music, and animation quality. You made a lot happen in 30 seconds. I'm impressed. Keep it up, dude! ;)

FL-Nordin responds:

thanks, i guess quality over quantity is the trick

[My Intro for Pierce Animation]

Pretty cute. Reminds me of the Pixar intro. Animation quality is good, and the little brass flair at the end ties it together well. Solid work, man.

alienanimation responds:

Thank You!

[Monster VS StickMan]

This is really cool. I love the interactive element of it. Impressive that you both animated it and wrote the music too. Keep it up, man. ;)

JohnCage1997 responds:

As much as I love animating as a hobby and create music just for fun, (and a GMod-er)
Thank you! Much appreciated! :D

[Prickly bum]

This is pretty cool. The animation quality is good, and I like the music. It doesn't really loop that well, though, and could use some more structure. I think it would be better if you expanded on it a bit. Still, nice work, though. ;)

chronicbite responds:

Right, so maybe i should have explained this. This is not an original entry per say. It is a 6 sec contribution that will be par of a biger project. The chalenge was to interpret the music however we wanted... Thanks anyway for the revew, i really wish i had more time to work on this.

[Running Short]

The animation quality is pretty good, but I think this could've really used some more plot/dialogue. There isn't even any sound - some music would really help make this more interesting. I'm not sure why it needed to be almost 2 minutes long either. You should keep working at it! ;)

ZairikAzrael responds:

Mostly for testing purposes, to go through the process to see if my machine could render it, convert it, upload it, otherwise there's no point trying for a longer animation next time. Also, YouTube has a thing about videos under 60 seconds, even if it's 59 seconds, and also it'll round down a second sometimes as well even when I've tried in Adobe Premiere. Audio wasn't a concern as much as the rest, and I didn't feel like pasting some creative commons or royalty free bland music over it. I will have more to show in my work on my next animation.

[Juan and Carlos]

Not bad. Voice acting is pretty good, and the animation quality is higher than average for NG. I might recommend using some reverb/flanger effects if you were going for a sort of spooky ending, instead of just increasing the volume on the laughter. It's really short as it is, though. You should expand more upon this idea. ;)

JoeMcFatman responds:

thank's man really appreciate the feed back

[Let's Go to Minecon]

Hmm...the voice acting and animation were really good, and the plot was pretty amusing. I thought the facial expressions were particularly well done. The language was bothering me a bit, though. I think this should be rated "M," not "T." Otherwise, it was definitely entertaining throughout. Nice work! ;)

sweetcommando responds:

hmmmm yea, might have to change that

[Greedy Adventurer]

This is really cool, and a nice surprise that you're extending your skills on NG to the realm of movies. ;) I don't know much about animation, but I think you did a really good job for your first film, and I like the attempt at plot development and all. That said, it was kind of hard to follow the story. I was confused by the end. Overall, though, I liked it a lot. You have real potential, my friend, and I loved the music, btw! :D

OatmealPecheneg responds:

I glad to see that you enjoy this movie. Storyline is hard implemented becouse i tried to make it in easy way :-). Next time i try to make story more understandable.

[Guffies episode 1]

It's actually really good. The quality of animation and sound was really high. My only complaints are that the dialogue was a bit dull at times, and that their lips rarely moved besides to express that they were talking/not talking. Overall, though, nice work, man! ;D

LaDewsWin responds:

Thank you :) I know the lip-syncing is bad, I just couldn't motivate myself to finish it properly, so I stuck to a simpler version so I could finally get this thing out. Next episode will be much better ;)