TaintedLogic's audio Reviews on Newgrounds

[-Showtime- (AAG OST)]

This is another awesome short tune! The mood is fun and exciting and bouncy, and the instruments are cool and fun as well. I'm going to nitpick this one a bit, though, just because I know you can handle it. ;) First of all, when the drums come in at :02, it seems very sudden given the volume of the bass at the very beginning. I also think you transition between moods a little too quickly, even if the game is supposed to be fast-paced. For example, the part at :30 is very rhythmic and even angry, while the part at 1:04 is very cute and upbeat and melodic. I'm also not a fan of fade-out endings, and I would've liked it if you had this track loop. However, I do understand that you made this for a game and that you had to make the audio fit the game as best as possible. I still love the synths and energy. It's very catchy and engaging, too, and fitting for the game, I'm sure. Keep up the good work, Waterflame! :D

[Nostalgic Dreams]

I like the emotion and the melodies. The quirky instruments were cool, especially that ghost-y back-up melody instrument at :15. I like the structure and transitions. It's a pretty solid piece. I suppose one complaint I have is that it gets way too busy after around 30 seconds in. There's just too much going on imo - it makes it hard/confusing to listen to. I love the piano and flute harmonies at 1:28, though, and how you then transition into the last refrain. While I'm nitpicking, I think the drums could've been a little more interesting, though. That said, overall, I like this one a lot. Keep up the good work, LunacyEcho! ;D

LunacyEcho responds:

I didn't actually think the instrument choice was that good at first, but I was too lazy to change it so I kept it and adapted it to the best of my abilities. I'm glad you liked it!

As for the tons of instruments, yeah. I agree. I guess I got used to listening to it, but I can see how it might be a bit much for anyone newly listening to it.

I think the transition I used into that final part would work better in a more electronically-themed song, since the basic driving instrument was the drums. Speaking of, I see what you mean by them being boring. I mean, I literally just looped it from around 1:15-1:45.

Anyways, thanks a lot for commenting!

[-Home sweet home- (AAG OST)]

I love the quirky synths and the energy and mood. It's very upbeat and fast-paced and fun! :D It loops really well, and I love the melodies that come in at :36. Nice work! I should check out this game! ;D

Waterflame responds:

Thanks :D Its in the featured of this week on ng!

[The Flute Song]

Yay! :D It's very cute and catchy. I love all the instruments and the melodies, too. I appreciated the structuring, even if it is a really short piece. Maybe it'd be good for a children's learning game or something...idk. I love the upbeat and cute mood, though, and it could even potentially make a pretty good loop, too. Nice work! ;D

LunacyEcho responds:

I think I stole the chord progression from that Discovery Channel "I love the blah" song. Maybe. I'm not quite sure.

Children's music, huh? Yeah, makes sense. I was considering making this into a loop, but I made it a while ago and only recently decided to put it on Newgrounds. In other words, you can thank human laziness that this isn't a loop.

Thanks for commenting, TheDoor! I appreciate you taking time out of your religiously upheld commenting to come to my little shadow of the Internet.

[canopy melody]

I absolutely love the mood and instruments. The combination of the prominent bass and dreamy melodies in the beginning is really interesting. I love the percussion, and the structure and transitions are very good. It's also very climactic, and I love the melodies. Everything about this piece is so beautiful, perhaps with the exception of the last chord, which felt a little irrelevant. Still, why is this rated a 3/5?! This is yet more excellent work, Johnfn! Great job! :D

johnfn responds:

YOU ARE A REVIEWING MACHINE. I'm glad you liked this one (I did too). I've basically given up on gaining any sort of meaningful information out of ratings hahah. P.S. I think you can learn to love the last chord. It's got dat jazz feel!

[Quietude]

I love the intellectual and tranquil mood. The instruments were beautiful. At times, I think the piano riffs are a little too busy when compared to the calming strings, though. It definitely doesn't feel complete - I would love to see some more structuring and expansion on these ideas. Overall, though, it has a lot of potential and I commend you for your good work. Keep at it, B. Tibbetts! ;D

BenTibbetts responds:

OK. Thank you for your comment. :)

[you are not alone]

The chords are very soothing, and the slow start of the piece really adds to the emotion. As always, I loved the melodies and atmospheric space. The beat that comes in at 1:53 was quite unexpected, although I really like how it gives it a bit more energy there. Around 2:35 - 3:15, there were some eccentric harmonies which I wasn't really sure what to make of. I think they really add a new dimension to the interpretation of the song, which I suppose is a good thing. The kick at 3:29 felt a little out-of-place. Maybe you could transition into 3:45 similarly to how you transitioned into 1:53. I like how the beat at 1:53 is mixed and distorted so that it almost seems "hidden," although you didn't do that with the beat at 3:45. Perhaps you should, at least until 4:17. I think it will be fitting with the style of the piece. The glitch-y transition leading into 4:16 felt really climactic and cool, though, and I love the bit at 4:17. Overall, excellent work as always, Johnfn! This one is probably my favorite of the 3 pieces you've submitted in the last 24 hours.

johnfn responds:

Thanks! You have a lot of really good suggestions and ideas. I especially like the idea of reintroducing the filtered beat rather than just bringing in the kick for the buildup, that's probably something I'll do in the future. I have to say though, I'm confused that you say this one is your favorite but you give the other one a higher score!

[just hold on]

I like the mood and atmospheric synths, although I feel like you've used many of them before. Those dreamy riffs are beautiful. I love the modulations at 1:25. It does seem a little bit minimalistic at times, like at 1:50, but in a way that adds to the tranquil mood and creates some valuable dynamic contrast. At 3:18, the synths and pads started to sound really harsh, although I like how you transitioned back into the coda. I'm not even going to reprimand you for your fade-out ending this time, Johnfn. If it's really that deeply ingrained in your style and your identity and a musician, that's fine with me. ;) Overall, though, nice work! Waking up to 3 new tracks from you made me feel overwhelmed, but also happy! ;D

johnfn responds:

Yeahhhh when you go for that higher sound you always risk the frequency problems. Still glad you liked it.

Unlike my other songs for this one I really didn't want to go overboard with epicness or details or whatever, I felt like it'd work against the relaxing feel of the piece. Hence the more minimalistic arrangement as you pointed out.

I've come around to thinking that the fadeouts I've done in the past were usually not a good idea, especially with the hyper energetic tracks I was doing. But I still think that fadeouts in mellow tracks sound really beautiful ;-)

[Wasteland Overdrive]

I love the atmosphere and instruments - especially the drum kits. I love the combination of genres and the moods, too. The structure is good, but I wish there was a bit more dynamic contrast, just so it feels more climactic. The mixing is excellent, though, and this piece has just the right amount of reverb. I LOVE that snare that comes in at 2:18 and other places, as well as the flute-sounding percussive instrument and snare at the very beginning. Fantastic work overall. Keep it up, Deadlyfishes! :D

deadlyfishes responds:

"I wish there was a bit more dynamic contrast, just so it feels more climactic." It was designed this way to be fitting for use in the game. I actually did have more contrasting moments but it became too distracting for the game so I had to make it a bit less dynamic in terms of structure. Thanks for your review!

[We Are Strong]

I liked the instruments and mood, especially the synths that come in at :42. The edgy guitars and pads added a lot to the piece as well. I liked the progression, too. However, I'm not sure I like the vocals too much - they're a little repetitive and sound very angry/irrelevant. I wish they were at least sung instead of spoken. The fade-out ending was a little dull, too. Perhaps this would make a good loop. I like the beats and mood, though. Overall, it's a cool piece. Keep at it, Mistarogerz! ;D

mistarogerz responds:

It was in fact a little bit angry. I was angry that I could'nt think of any more vocals. LOL! Maybe I'll sing on my next one!